Did you know that in 2023, the IRS (Internal Revenue Service) collected more than $104.1 billion in unpaid assessments on returns filed with additional tax due, netting about $68.3 billion after credit transfers? The IRS is responsible for collecting federal taxes, enforcing tax laws, and making sure that both individuals and businesses follow the U.S. tax code.
When a person or a business disagrees with a tax decision from the IRS or another tax authority, they might have to consider the civil litigation process to settle the disagreement. Administrative appeals to the tax authority are usually the initial step.
If this doesn't work, the case may go to court. Once both sides present their evidence, a judge or jury will make a decision based on the relevant tax rules and the facts of the case. Tax attorneys from Tax Smith suggest that if you’re going through tax disputes, having an attorney could save you hundreds or thousands of dollars.
Learn more about the civil litigation process to make sure you're not overpaying or being unfairly penalized.
Jurisdiction and Venue
Understanding the concepts of jurisdiction and venue is essential for determining the appropriate place for resolving tax matters in civil litigation. The venue determines the location where a court will address a case within its jurisdiction. Tax disputes are typically resolved based on where the taxpayer lives or where the tax issue arises. To prevent jurisdictional issues, be sure the court can hear the matter.
The venue for the trial determines where it should take place. Choosing the right venue impacts various logistical aspects, such as the travel arrangements for witnesses and the legal team, as well as the overall convenience of the proceedings. Having a good understanding of jurisdiction and venue from the start can make civil litigation easier and help avoid unnecessary delays.
Las Vegas civil attorney Ken R. Ashworth recommends bringing on board a skilled tax attorney, particularly if you find yourself in the midst of intricate civil litigation, as they can assist in handling the process with ease.
Pleadings and Discovery
After determining the appropriate jurisdiction and venue for tax disputes, the next step in the civil litigation process is to start the pleadings and enter the discovery phase.
Pleadings are official written documents submitted to the court that detail the claims and defenses of each party involved. The documents consist of the complaint, which initiates the lawsuit by detailing the plaintiff's claims, and the answer, where the defendant addresses those claims.
Discovery is the stage where both sides collect information from one another to strengthen their arguments. This stage usually includes asking for documents, written questions, oral testimony under oath, and occasionally requests for admission.
By engaging in discovery, both sides can deepen their understanding of the facts and evidence related to the case, which can guide their strategies as they move ahead. It's crucial to engage actively in this phase to ensure you're well-prepared for the subsequent stages of the litigation process.
Pretrial Motions and Conferences
Pretrial motions and discussions can help address legal issues and make court proceedings more efficient. The court receives official pretrial motions before the trial. These motions could lead to dismissal, seek summary judgment, or aim to exclude certain evidence. Pretrial motions help to clarify legal arguments, narrow the scope of the trial, and settle certain issues before the trial begins.
However, conferences allow parties to discuss the case with the court informally. These sessions can assist in clarifying legal matters, fostering a shared understanding, and exploring possible settlements. Attending pretrial conferences helps everyone involved come together to agree on trial schedules, procedures, and what to expect.
Trial Proceedings and Evidence
Tax dispute trials require persuasive evidence to support your case. Documents, witness testimony, expert opinions, and other exhibits can support your claim. To strengthen your legal case, consider hiring a tax lawyer to help you organize and present your evidence logically and persuasively.
When sharing evidence, it is important to follow the established rules that dictate what can be shown in court. Your lawyer will make sure to authenticate the evidence to establish its credibility and relevance to the case. Additionally, consider the weight of each piece of evidence and how it contributes to your overall argument.
Both sides can present and cross-examine evidence throughout the trial. Preparation, organization, and thorough evidence presentation can affect trial outcomes. Therefore, plan and choose the strongest evidence to support your position.
Post-Trial Options and Appeals
The trial result gives you many post-trial alternatives for your tax dispute case. If the ruling was in your favor, you have the option to drop the case. If you disagree with the decision, you can appeal with the help of your lawyer. An appeal asks a higher court to examine a trial court's ruling. Appeal deadlines are tight, so act quickly.
Another option is to seek a post-trial settlement with the opposing party. Settlement discussions can occur at any stage of the litigation process, including after a trial. This option allows both parties to reach a mutually agreeable resolution without the need for further court proceedings.
You could also try mediation or arbitration. These post-trial tax dispute resolution techniques are less formal and cheaper. You must analyze the advantages and cons of each choice before choosing the best one for your circumstance.
Conclusion
Going through the civil litigation process for tax disputes can be complex and challenging, but by understanding the different stages of the process and seeking guidance from an experienced lawyer, whether you settle before trial or proceed through an appeal, it’s important to explore all avenues of resolution to ensure the best possible outcome for your tax dispute. With the right guidance, you can address the issue efficiently and avoid unnecessary complications.
Related Content